by Mr. Tweedy on Fri Sep 04, 2009 5:03 am
I think the basic idea is really interesting and fresh, but I don't like your ideas for the end. Having the terrors be human just seems... weak. There's no mystery there, no nightmare horror. It just makes it like a video game: Human players assuming fantasy avatars to fight each other without personal risk. (If there were personal risk, then Harold's nightly victories would soon rid the world of terrors, since the humans who they represent would be dying and hence unable to fight the next night.) I also don't like the idea of MOM. It seems too new-agey, touchy-feely, Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, pseudo-buddhist... yeah.
The terrors absolutely must be something mysterious for them to be effective. The human fighting them can't know exactly what they are or what they're capable of, otherwise they won't be scary. In other words, the Terrors must themselves be nightmare-like, not just inhabit nightmares. I'd ditch MOM too, but that isn't essential. Terrors being mysterious is essential.
What I think would be totally badass is if the terrors are humans... from a parallel universe. The people over there are utterly decadent and vile Marquis de Sade types who have destroyed their own version of Earth through their greed and cruelty, and so they're trying to cross over to our universe and take over our Earth before they all die on theirs. They're trying to colonize. In the nightmares, a Terror actually kills the mind of a person, then takes over their body: The person wakes up as someone else, someone evil. You could have it that the Terrors are all ancient post-humans, and assign them correspondingly creepy personalities.
That's my 2¢.